« links for 2006-09-07 | Main | Brock's death brings more media crassness »

08 September 2006

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c532753ef00d83460115d69e2

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Irwin's death attracts the serial headline hunters:

» September 8th: This weeks top 5 from Strive Notes
Well the summer holidays are definitely over the pace at Strive has picked up! So much so, that I struggled to keep up with my reading this week. But I did manage to enjoy some pretty compelling posts Id like to share.  Here they are in pa... [Read More]

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

There are also people in the audience who agree with Hamilton and Greer for the most part and whose opinions haven't otherwise been reflected in media coverage of Irwin's death.

I said on a podcast the day after Irwin's death that it was family tragedy, not a national tragedy. I was shouted down.

I'll put my cards on the table and say that I've a lot of time for what Hamilton and Greer said and I know I'm not alone. I know also that most of my friends who agree with me won't say so publically because of the ad hominem response. I heard Greer described last night in quite graphic terms and was told she wasn't welcome in this - her - country.

Sorry - "publicly"

Although I was very surprised at the scale of public grief over Mr. Irwin's death, I also thought Ms. Greer's commentary mean,unnecessary and of course insensitive. I presumed her reason for making such inflammatory comments was a similar one to that which took her into and out of the British Big Brother household. A severe case of limelight deficiency.

As someone who would usually be supportive of the social research work Hamilton does through his think tank, my first reaction was to tell him to shut the heck up.

Talk about prissy and stuck up.

But then again I view Irwin through the eyes of a migrant to Australia so maybe I don't have the same cultural baggage to carry as some native Australians do.

Greer is as much a serial contrarian as a publicist. Which is necessary. I think she lapped up the calls for her banning from Australian soil. Interesting to see one self-publicist criticise another.

Hamilton's piece actually seemed pretty reasonable from my perspective.

I am not a native Australian either. But then I found my fellow Britons' public anguish over Diana incomprehensible.

I notice that the tributes to Steve Irwin focused on his conservation work rather than "Crocodile Hunter: Collision Course".

With the news this afternoon of Peter Brock's tragic death, I hope we won't get the self-publicists and contrarians coming out with diatribes about motor sport etc. But its bound to happen. Who will be the first to come out and puncture the 'national grief' this time?

Re Diana, Princess of Wales, I do get a kick out of pointing out that this "most hardworking of royals" was on her sixth international holiday of the year when she died, and it was only August.

I'm British, too, and I was never gladder to live abroad than when it happened; another family tragedy, not a national one.

It was funny that as Greer was talking about how Irwin treated animals disrespectfully, ACA should choose to play a clip of him swinging a snake about. Maybe the editor agreed with her, even as Stefanovic was making a fool of himself beating her with the popular stick. Thank God for YouTube.

As for Peter Brock, you're certainly safe from me as I'd not heard of him till just now. Far worse than any puncturing of national grief, I think, is this line that Irwin's family have had to endure of him dying "doing what he loved". Does it really comfort anyone that he died filming a documentary not crossing the road? Or that Brock died at the wheel, not falling down stairs?

I found the Diana nonsense revolting, still do. As an unreconstructed republican (of the direct election variety) I believe they are all a waste of space, and I fail to see what she actually did except fulfill a minimalist program of 'visits'.
I think the 'died doing what he loved' thing is just another awful cliché.
Even better when some goose says "it was ironic that he died do what he loved" or similar.
These are episodes are times to just not watch, listen or read in my opinion.
And I resent people like Greer and Hamiliton who simply prolong the misery of having to endure a 'national outpouring of grief' or any other supposed media-induced frenzy.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Trevor Cook

  • Trevor is a doctoral student in politics at the University of Sydney. He also tutors in the area of Australian foreign and defence policy. He has been blogging since November 2003 and over the past decade he has written many articles on politics, public relations and social media for newspapers, magazines and websites (ABC Unleashed, Crikey, New Matilda and Online Opinion).

Google ads

Twitter Updates

    follow me on Twitter

    Your email address:


    Powered by FeedBlitz

    Search

    • Google

      WWW
      trevorcook.typepad.com
    Blog powered by TypePad
    Member since 02/2004

    Disclaimer


    • The views expressed on this site are those of the authors and commenters and not necessarily those of employers, clients and other third parties.